Everything you need to know about choosing a home ice maker

When the weather’s hot, having plenty of ice on hand to keep your drinks cold is a must. But even if your fridge is equipped with an ice maker, you may not be able to produce as much ice as quickly as you need it.
A dedicated home ice maker can create as much ice as you need for parties, barbecues and other group gatherings. If you’re thinking about investing in a home ice maker, here are all the facts you need to make the right choice.
How does an ice maker work?
Most home ice makers have a tank or reservoir that you fill with water. When the maker is turned on, the water is pumped from the tank to a container where prongs full of refrigerant freeze the water until it forms ice. The ice maker shifts the prongs into warming mode when the ice is made, so the ice cubes easily fall from the container into a bucket. You must empty the bucket and refill the water tank as necessary to ensure a steady supply of ice.
Ice maker benefits
If your refrigerator has a built-in ice maker or you’re used to making ice in your freezer with ice cube trays, you may be wondering if you really need a home ice maker. But there are quite a few advantages to having a dedicated ice maker:
Home ice makers produce large amounts of ice quickly. A built-in fridge ice maker typically produces less than a pound an hour, while ice cube trays yield 18 cubes or fewer at a time. A standalone home ice maker can usually make between 24 and 50 pounds a day, so they work well if you go through a lot of ice or entertain regularly and need enough ice for a large group.
Stand-alone ice makers are typically portable. If you need ice for camping, boating, tailgating or RV trips, you can easily bring the appliance along.
How to choose an ice maker
Figure out how much ice you need
While standalone or portable ice makers produce a greater volume of ice than a built-in refrigerator ice maker or freezer ice trays, there’s some variation among machines. For example, some ice makers produce about 20 pounds of ice daily, while others can make as much as 50 pounds in a 24-hour period. Most models make 24 to 35 pounds daily, which is usually enough for households that use a great deal of ice or entertain regularly.
Decide whether you need a portable model
Most standalone ice makers offer a compact, lightweight design, so they’re easy to move around. Other ice makers are large or designed for under-counter installation to provide an extremely large volume of ice, so they’re not portable. If you want to take your ice maker on the go or just prefer a model you can easily take in and out of a cabinet, opt for a portable model. If you need a machine that can produce as much ice as possible, though, go with a stationary ice maker.
Determine what type of ice you need
You might think that all ice cubes are the same, but there’s quite a bit of choice regarding the shape and size of the cubes that an ice maker produces. You can find ice makers that make traditional cubes, half cubes, crescent, nugget or bullet ice cubes, depending on your preferences. In addition, some models can produce multiple types of ice cubes for added versatility. You can also find ice makers that let you choose between small, medium and large cube sizes.
Identify how quickly you need your ice
If your household goes through ice quickly, you should also consider how fast an ice maker can produce a batch of ice. In most cases, a maker won’t start making ice as soon as you pour water into the tank. Instead, it can take anywhere from five to 20 minutes to produce its first batch. Remember that some machines may take less time to make subsequent batches once they’re warmed up.
Consider special features
Some home ice makers offer special features that make them easier to use and maintain. Choosing an ice maker with refrigerated storage can be convenient, so you don’t need to transfer it to your freezer to prevent melting. You may also want a model with a self-cleaning feature, which makes maintenance much easier. Some ice makers also have a built-in water filter to ensure you get the best-tasting ice possible.
FAQ
Q. Do I need a home ice maker if my fridge has a built-in ice maker?
A. It depends on how much ice you typically go through and how much ice your built-in maker can produce. If you don’t use much ice daily, your fridge’s ice maker is likely sufficient. But if you and your family go through large quantities of ice or regularly host large gatherings, a standalone ice maker is probably more efficient.
Q. How often should I clean my home ice maker?
A. You should deep clean your ice maker every two to six months. If you use your machine often, though, you may want to give it a good cleaning monthly.
What you need to buy for home ice making
Newair Countertop Ice Maker
This BPA-free countertop ice maker can produce up to 50 pounds of ice each 24-hour period, so it’s ideal for large families or anyone who entertains regularly. It only requires six minutes to make a batch and has a programmable timer to prevent you from running out of ice.
GE Profile Opal Countertop Nugget Ice Maker
If you like soft, crunchy ice, this nugget ice maker can produce up to 24 pounds per day. Its large-capacity side bin can hold 3 pounds of ice at a time, but the machine is still portable enough to take on the go.
Frigidaire Portable Compact Ice Maker
Producing up to 26 pounds per day, this ice maker has a slim, compact design perfect for small kitchens, boats or RVs. It has a user-friendly LED control panel and offers two size settings, depending on your needs.
Silonn Countertop Ice Maker
This speedy ice maker can produce its first batch of ice in just six minutes and make up to 26 pounds every 24 hours. It is extremely quiet during operation and has a transparent lid that lets you keep track of how much ice you’ve made.
Crownful Ice Maker Machine for Countertop
This compact ice maker fits perfectly in any wet bar and can make up to 26 pounds every 24 hours. It also offers extremely quiet operation and user-friendly one-button operation.
Euhomy Nugget Ice Maker
With a high-efficiency compressor, this nugget ice maker offers a continuous ice-making process that sets it apart from other models. It can produce up to 26 pounds a day and has an ice basket that holds up to 3.3 pounds at a time.
Prices listed reflect time and date of publication and are subject to change.
Check out our Daily Deals for the best products at the best prices and sign up here to receive the BestReviews weekly newsletter full of shopping inspo and sales.
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. BestReviews and its newspaper partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.